My reviews (21)

Refreshing Watermelon Sorbet

This recipe is for a really refreshing watermelon sorbet. With the use of an ice cream maker, it's easy to make. This sorbet will be welcomed during the hot summer months.
Reviews (21)

31 May 2010
Reviewed by: ANDIALEIGH
With one cup of simple syup this is easily a 5 star recipe. And so easy. I'll never throw leftover watermelon away again. Tip, go ahead and make your simple syrup as instructed, but only use 1 cup in the sorbet. Save what's left in the fridge for mojitos or whatever strikes you. We always keep some on hand.
(Review from Allrecipes US | Canada)
29 Jun 2010
Reviewed by: Melissa Goff
Well, this was totally hard to rate. I looked at this recipe a few times before deciding to make and seriously read all the reviews. I started out with the 1:1cup ratio water and sugar, the 1/4 lime juice and I hard packed my watermelon in the measurements of 4 cups. I strained the pulp because my watermelon had seeds. I found that my melon was not that sweet...And the lime juice over powered the watermelon flavor. So I had to increase another 1:1cup water and sugar. Still tasted lime juice above the watermelon. So I added another 1:1cup water and sugar and then it wasn't sweet with watermelon flavor....Bottom line was this. I did the exact recipe but I ended up increasing the watermelon to 8 cups of packed watermelon to get the desired flavor. I think if your watermelon is to sweet, then adjust(decrease) your simple syrup ratio to accomendate, if your melon was like mine, you'll have to increase. This recipe is one you need to watch soley because of the watermelon. If I had realized my melon wasn't sweet, I would have just decreased the lime juice. My kids liked it, but my son said he liked it better as juice then frozen. I thought it was spot on the watermelon flavor when the recipe was done, but I would totally wait 24 hours before serving to make sure it's nice and firm. It melts way to quickly after a couple of hours and that was after I used an ice cream maker.
(Review from Allrecipes US | Canada)
09 Sep 2009
Reviewed by: pamberjp
This recipe was way too sweet. I would suggest trying this with about 1/3 of the simple syrup, or less if you have a sweet enough melon.
(Review from Allrecipes US | Canada)
28 Feb 2011
Reviewed by: gloriam3
Made this using the 1/3 cup simple syrup. Huge, huge hit with my husband. I still thought it was a little too sweet. Just an addition--I bought two large watermelons at the end of last summer, made the simple syrup and added the blended watermelon. Then I froze it in one quart containers (the same size as my ice cream machine). We were able to have watermelon sorbet in the middle of winter simply by thawing the mixture and placing it in the ice cream machine and preceding with the recipe as follows. Made my first batch for this summer today and my hubs is a very happy man.
(Review from Allrecipes US | Canada)
13 Jun 2010
Reviewed by: Martha Cochell
I agree that, written as is, this sorbet would be terribly sweet. I used one cup of simple syrup and almost five cups of watermelon, and it's still pretty sweet, but also really refreshing. I didn't use an ice cream maker, just poured the mixture into a shallow dish and froze it. Then, once it's frozen, you can either scrape it with a fork or put it in a food processor. (Keep in mind that it melts very quickly.) Also, after combining the watermelon pulp with the simple syrup and lime juice, I pressed it through a sieve to get rid of the solids. Because, even though the watermelons say they're 'seedless', they still have those pesky white seeds that would make for an unappetizing final product.
(Review from Allrecipes US | Canada)
27 Aug 2010
Reviewed by: KANGZ
too sweet. made double amount that fit in my ice cream maker.
(Review from Allrecipes US | Canada)
06 Aug 2011
Reviewed by: Robert Yager
Awesome! Decrease the sugar a little or try some Agave Nectar instead.
(Review from Allrecipes US | Canada)
22 Jul 2011
Reviewed by: soupisgoodfood33
as is three stars. i tasted the mixture before i froze it and as is TOO SWEET. to remedy it and not waste it i added double the watermelon which i just smashed with a potato masher and didnt do the whole food processor step. i just smashed the watermelon ( 8 cups for the amount of simple syrup specified) and kept the lime juice the same and froze it in those popsicle maker things and dixie cups. my daughter loves these and we didnt waste any watermelon. i think this would also work with canteloupe or peaches its a good starting point.
(Review from Allrecipes US | Canada)
11 Jul 2011
Reviewed by: Dorothy Wagoner Howard
This is a yummy refreshing treat!!! I used only 1/2 the syrup and my family loves it! I will make this over and over again!
(Review from Allrecipes US | Canada)
25 Jul 2012
Reviewed by: DTRUBELA
II ended up with a dud watermelon from the grocery store- it was basically pink and not suitable for eating as a snack- I came accross this recipe and was able to salvage said $6 watermelon! I also cut the syrup ration by half and it was a hit! Will make again!
(Review from Allrecipes US | Canada)


My recently viewed recipes

My recent searches